The excitement around an Initial Public Offering (IPO) in India is often palpable. But for astute investors, a peculiar pattern emerges: the share price of a company in the unlisted market (pre-IPO) is often significantly higher than the price set for the official IPO.

For example, a major company like Tata Capital, ahead of its recent listing, saw its IPO price band set at a discount of over 50% compared to its last traded price in the unlisted market.

This isn’t an accident or a market failure; it’s a calculated strategy driven by market dynamics, psychology, and the fundamental differences between a regulated public offering and an unregulated private market.

Here is a breakdown of the key factors that cause a company’s IPO price to be lower than its unlisted market price in India.

---

1. The “Leave Something on the Table” Principle

The most significant reason for the discount is strategic. Companies and their investment bankers deliberately price the IPO lower than their true intrinsic valuation—and certainly lower than the price in the speculative unlisted market.

• Retail Investor Attraction: An IPO must be attractive to ensure massive oversubscription, which creates positive buzz and momentum. The primary incentive for retail investors to apply is the promise of a “listing gain”—a quick profit on the listing day. By offering a discount, the company ensures that a substantial gain is possible, thereby guaranteeing high demand.
• Mitigating Risk: The IPO price is fixed weeks before the listing. By pricing it conservatively, the company creates a buffer against any adverse market or regulatory news that might emerge between the final price declaration and the listing day. This protects the issue from listing below the offer price, which can severely damage investor confidence.

2. The Differences in Market Dynamics

The unlisted market (sometimes referred to as the pre-IPO or grey market) and the regulated IPO process operate under entirely different rules.

Feature	Unlisted Market (Pre-IPO)	Official IPO Price
Regulation	Unregulated, opaque, and highly illiquid.	Governed strictly by SEBI, fully regulated and transparent.
Price Discovery	Driven by demand-supply dynamics among a small pool of High-Net-Worth Individuals (HNIs) and brokers. Prices are highly volatile.	Determined by Merchant Bankers using detailed valuation models (DCF, peer multiples) and future projections.
Liquidity	Extremely Low. It is difficult to find a buyer/seller quickly.	High (Guaranteed). Upon listing, the shares can be bought/sold instantly on the exchange.
Supply	Limited supply, often consisting of shares held by employees, ex-employees, or early investors. Limited supply with high HNI demand inflates the price.	Large, defined supply that must be fully sold to the public.

In the unlisted space, investors pay a premium because of the lack of supply and the high risk associated with illiquidity. In the regulated IPO, the company offers a discount in exchange for guaranteed high liquidity and broad market participation.

3. The Impact of Scarcity and Speculation

The high price in the unlisted market is often purely a reflection of speculative frenzy, particularly for well-known or fundamentally strong companies like NSE or Tata Group entities.

• Scarcity Premium: Unlisted shares are scarce. HNIs, who are willing to pay a premium to secure a large position before the IPO, bid up the price. They are paying for access and scarcity, which is a separate cost from the stock’s fundamental value.
• IPO Anticipation: The primary driver for the unlisted price is the belief that the stock will list much higher on the exchange. This IPO anticipation creates a demand bubble in the unregulated market.

4. Valuation Methodologies and Due Diligence

The valuation used for the IPO is far more rigorous and conservative than the valuation implied by the unlisted price.

• Conservative Valuation: The IPO’s price band is based on comprehensive due diligence, audited financials, and a comparison with listed peers. Merchant bankers use conservative metrics to ensure the long-term sustainability of the valuation.
• Unlisted Markups: Prices in the unlisted market are often inflated due to markups, commissions, and the opaque pricing mechanism used by various private brokers, which may not accurately reflect the company’s true intrinsic worth.

Key Takeaway for Investors

The discount in the IPO price is a deliberate mechanism to reward new investors, ensure a successful issue, and provide a cushion against market volatility.

While the high unlisted price can be tempting, investors should always focus on the fundamental valuation presented in the IPO documents, not the speculative premium of the unregulated market. The discount is your primary incentive—it is the company’s way of ensuring you walk away with a profit on Day 1.